5 from 2 votes

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating




12 Comments

    1. Good Morning Nini, you sure can. It’s listed in the Storage and and Reheating section of the post. Thank you and have a lovely day 🙂

    1. That’s a good question, Terri. We have not tried using vanilla pudding. With that being said, Kim’s grandmother made it using fresh strawberries and a different flavor of pudding. So, I feel like you could make that substitution without any issues. I hope that answers your question. Have a lovely day 🙂

  1. 5 stars
    I love this dessert, but am wondering: Would it be just as yummy if I used sugar-free pudding, low-fat milk and low-fat cream cheese? Have you tried it that way?

    1. Good Morning Nancy, great question! No, we have not tried it that way. Personally, I don’t care for the taste of sugar-free desserts. I feel the sweeteners tend to have a chemical after-taste and the lack of fat leaves the dish flat. However, that’s just how my taste buds work.

      If you enjoy the flavor of sugar-free and low-fat alternatives, then I would say yes, go for it. Also, I would never deter someone from modifying any recipe to meet his or her dietary needs. That’s what cooking is all about 🙂 In fact, I modify recipes for personal use all the time. For example, when a recipe uses cream cheese to thicken a dish and give it a creamy texture, I typically make a blonde roux instead. By using butter, cream, and flour.

      So, anytime you want to change a recipe to fit your dietary or taste preferences, I encourage it! I hope this response helps and we wish you a lovely weekend 🙂

  2. 5 stars
    You say to make the crust up to an inch thick, will it shrink down so it’s not too thick? Almost an inch seems awfully thick. I’m making this tonight for tomorrow and it sounds yummy.

    1. Hi, Denise! According to my grandma’s written instructions it should be about an inch thick. However, depending on what brand of pan you use it may be little less. We have two different brands of pans, and supposedly they are the same size. However, the crust is a slightly different thickness from one pan to the next. It’s kind of strange. Thanks for stopping by. Let us know if you have any more questions. 🙂

    1. Good afternoon, Darline! Thank you for commenting and asking a great question. I understand there are different sizes of boxed pudding. I plugged the numbers into my calculator and it looks like you would need 5.57 boxes of the 1.4-ounce pudding for the entire recipe. So, I would round up to 6 boxes because having a little extra pudding shouldn’t hurt the dish. Thank you again for commenting and have a lovely Wednesday.